Two doors, two lives

The feast day of St Alphonsus Rodriguez (31 October) coincides with Martin Luther Day/Reformation Day. Fr Andrew Hamilton SJ reflects on the similarities between two very different figures.

30th Oct 2026
Read Time: 4 minutes
30th Oct 2026, Reading time: 4 minutes

 SHOWING THE WAY TO GOD 

By Fr Andrew Hamilton SJ
Eureka Street consulting editor and writer at Jesuit Social Services

During our lives we have some control over what we do and the company we keep. We can’t control, however, the days of our birth and death. Sometimes two famous people who died on the same day of the year would not have chosen their companions. But those who later notice the shared dates might find them thought-provoking.

That is the case with Martin Luther and Alphonsus Rodriguez. At first sight they could not have been more different. Luther was German, well-educated and a university teacher, who became a Monk and subsequently left the Catholic Church. Alphonsus Rodriguez was Spanish, born in Luther’s later years, uneducated, ran his family business and married, and became a Jesuit brother in an intensely Catholic Spain.

Martin Luther and Alphonsus Rodriguez were similar, however, in facing personal crises. Luther was deeply religious but scrupulous and unhappy. He found peace in recognising the unmerited grace of God. This led him to protest against what he saw were the practices in the Church that suggested that salvation could be earned. The protest led to the separation of the Reformed Churches from the Catholic Church. It created hostility between Catholics and Protestants. But it also contributed to needed reform within the Catholic Church.

Alphonsus married at 26 and had two children. When he was 31, his wife and two children died, and later his third. He became deeply, almost obsessively, religious and wanted to become a priest. After unsuccessfully trying to study, he sought to become a Jesuit. He was admitted as a Brother when he was 40, and was sent to the College on the island of Mallorca. There he was porter, a role that made him greet guests and pass messages to the community. He was the face of the community, and was a model of kindness and hospitality, as well as of wisdom to visitors. His geniality and faithfulness in his work ran together with scrupulousness in his spiritual life and prayer.

One everyday object that connects Alphonsus and Luther is the door. Luther is famously remembered as having nailed his Ninety-Five Theses to the door of All Saints’ Church in Wittenburg in 1517, although some historians doubt whether this really happened. Meanwhile, Alphonsus was the man who met guests at the door in Mallorca.

They had other things in common, despite their difference in education, public profile and relationship with the Catholic Church. Both confronted similar doubts about God’s love, both found consolation in a Christian faith and life cut to its essentials. Luther found it in a radical faith in a loving God which was stripped of practices that obscured it. Alphonsus found it in a simple life of service that echoed God’s hospitality. Both of them lived with the wounds they bore and would have laughed at the idea that they were saints.

Catholics of an earlier generation would have been shocked at a Catholic article which praised Luther and the Protestant tradition. Now, however, the Reformation stirs in many Catholics the mixed response that a bitter divorce in a previous generation of a family might evoke. Within it is the pity and shame that we should have allowed a relationship to come to this, and regret at all the hatred and prejudice that followed from the divorce and separation within the family. Within this response, too, is admiration and gratitude for the richness and generosity found in families on both sides of the initial divide, and the desire for a full reconciliation. In the human world Reformation is never complete, and doors aren’t closed forever.

Fr Andrew Hamilton SJ is a life member of the Australasian Catholic Press Association.

Saint Alphonsus Rodriguez SJ (left) and Martin Luther. Illustration concept by Janark Gray using Canva AI.

Share This